Shifting $300K from price to consulting fees can cost more in tax

Key Takeaways

Many buyers want the seller to stay after closing to introduce customers, train staff, maintain supplier relationships, and transfer operational knowledge. The consulting agreement defines the seller's responsibilities, but it also affects the seller's after-tax proceeds, payment timing, and whether the buyer can terminate those payments before the transition period ends.

SBA rules now permit a longer transition. Under SOP 50 10 8.1, effective October 1, 2026, a seller in a qualifying initial acquisition or business expansion may remain as a consultant for up to 24 months in total, including extensions. The previous limit was 12 months. In these transactions, the seller generally cannot remain an officer, director, stockholder, or employee following a complete change of ownership. Different rules apply to certain owner buyouts and employee ownership transactions. Buyers and sellers need to align the consulting arrangement with the lender's requirements before closing.

The longer window also creates more opportunities to structure payments as consulting compensation rather than purchase consideration. The distinction matters because federal law taxes the two payments differently. Goodwill proceeds may qualify for long-term capital gains treatment, with a maximum federal rate of 20% and a possible additional 3.8% net investment income tax. Consulting fees are generally ordinary income, potentially taxed at 37%, and may also be subject to self-employment taxes. For 2026, the 12.4% Social Security component applies up to the $184,500 annual earnings limit, while the 2.9% Medicare component has no earnings ceiling.

Consider a $4 million business sale where the buyer proposes paying $3.7 million at closing and another $300,000 through a two-year consulting agreement, with $150,000 paid annually. Assuming the $300,000 represents taxable long-term capital gain, the federal capital gains tax would be $60,000 at 20%, or $71,400 if the additional 3.8% tax applies. If the seller pays the same amount as consulting income to an independent contractor already in the 37% federal bracket, combined income and self-employment taxes could reach about $145,500 over two years. Actual liabilities depend on the seller's tax basis, other income, deductions, and business structure.

Qualifying consulting expenses are generally deductible under ordinary business expense rules in the appropriate tax year. In this example, the buyer could deduct $150,000 in each of the first two years. By comparison, acquired goodwill generally must be amortized over 15 years, producing approximately $20,000 in annual deductions on $300,000. 

The second issue is payment certainty. The seller receives cash at closing, while consulting fees are typically paid monthly or quarterly throughout the transition. Some agreements allow the buyer to terminate the relationship without cause. Unless the contract protects unpaid compensation, the seller may lose future payments when the arrangement ends. A seller who accepted $300,000 less at closing in exchange for consulting fees could therefore receive substantially less than the originally negotiated transaction value.

Sellers should negotiate the business purchase price and consulting compensation separately, with fees reflecting the actual services, time commitment, and responsibilities involved. If consulting payments are economically important to the transaction, the agreement should address early termination, payment obligations, and whether the buyer must pay remaining fees if it ends the arrangement without cause. Both parties should have tax and legal advisors review the allocation before signing the LOI, because changing the structure later can require renegotiating the sale's economics.

Come on board and a Breville Barista Express is yours. Yep, the $700 one.

Book a Strategy call with their team.

Middle-market business owners can access liquidity without selling their companies outright. A dividend recapitalization uses additional borrowing to fund shareholder distributions while retaining ownership, although the higher debt burden increases financial risk. For sponsor-backed businesses, a GP-led secondary can transfer an investment into a continuation fund, letting existing investors cash out while others retain exposure. Both structures require careful consideration of financing costs, investor interests, and future growth plans.

The International Business Brokers Association (IBBA) is hosting a three-day virtual learning summit designed for business brokers and professionals involved in valuing and selling small businesses. The program combines training on analyzing and recasting financial statements, introducing small-business pricing, and pricing businesses, with 32 credit hours available across the courses. For business owners, brokers, and M&A advisers, the sessions offer a closer look at how financial performance is normalized and business value is assessed during a sale. Details →

Fitch Ratings hosts its seventh annual Business Development Company (BDC) Conference at Hearst Tower in New York City, with virtual attendance also available. The half-day event brings together market participants and Fitch’s senior non-bank financial institutions analysts to examine trends, opportunities, and risks affecting business development companies. Topics include capital raising and liquidity across public and non-traded BDCs, the outlook for deal activity, pricing and financing terms, and portfolio credit quality. For lower-middle-market investors and deal professionals, the discussion offers context on the private-credit environment that can influence acquisition financing. Details →

US lower-middle-market deal activity remained subdued in the first half of 2026, with buyers and lenders continuing to take a selective approach. CIBC’s Q3 2026 Middle Market Monitor reports that average EBITDA multiples for $10 million to $500 million leveraged buyouts reached 7.1x in H1 2026, down slightly from 7.2x in 2024 and 2025 but above the 6.8x long-term average. Total debt utilization averaged 3.8x EBITDA, up from 3.7x in 2025, while business services transaction volume fell 15% year over year to 1,599 deals. Read →

In this episode, Dr. Michael Filosi discusses selling his dental practice to private equity after receiving four offers. He describes the challenge of informing his 35 employees about the acquisition and the mixed reactions that followed. Some congratulated him, while one employee expressed disappointment and walked out, and another avoided eye contact for three days. The conversation examines the emotional consequences of selling a business, particularly when employees have helped build it. For owners preparing to exit, the lesson is that a successful financial transaction doesn't guarantee employee support. How the sale affects staff relationships can be one of the hardest parts of leaving a business.